A Levittown man was found guilty last Friday connected to a road rage incident in Bensalem in which police shot him after he raised his gun, in the summer of 2025.
A Bucks County Jury found John Mathis 45, guilty of reckless endangerment illegal possession of a firearm, firearms not to be carried without a license, terroristic threats, possession of an instrument of crime, evading arrest and related offenses after a three day trial last week.
Senior Judge Thomas C. Branca, who oversaw the trial that began on Tuesday, deferred sentencing to January. Mathis has already been sentenced to 9 ½ to 19 years in state prison, and three years of probation, following a guilty verdict on a separate charge of aggravated assault by vehicle while DUI.
On Friday, Deputy District Attorney Megan Stricker delivered closing arguments to the jury, detailing the reckless road rage incident and the mounting string of dangerous decisions Mathis made along the way.
During the trial, Stricker and Deputy District Attorney Catherine Pirolli presented testimony from the victims, Bucks County Detectives, and Bensalem Township police officers that outlined the events of Aug. 2, 2025.
Public Safety Director William McVey said the original incident was called into 911 around 5:45 p.m.
Bensalem Township Police received a 911 call from a motorist who stated that a male on a motorcycle pointed a gun at him on Bristol Pike near the intersection of Biddle Lane.
The victim testified that Mathis pointed a handgun at their face and threatened to shoot and rob them before they were able to drive away and call for help. Police were advised that the motorcycle was still following the victim as they traveled northbound on Bristol Pike.
A Bensalem officer was in the area and caught up to them at Bristol Pike and Appleton Avenue, where the two vehicles were stopped in traffic. The officer pulled his vehicle between the complainant’s car and the motorcycle and exited the patrol vehicle. As the officer came around the rear of his vehicle, the motorcyclist was on foot with a gun in his right hand. The officer issued commands, but the motorcyclist did not comply. The Bensalem officer discharged his weapon and struck him; he fell to the ground.
Investigators recovered a black 9mm pistol at the scene that was not registered to Mathis. Due to a prior history of felony convictions, Mathis is legally prohibited from possessing firearms.
Mathis has a lengthy arrest and conviction record in Bucks County, authorities said, with several open cases at the time of the incident including a Bristol Twp road rage incident that occurred days before the Bensalem incident.
About an hour before the Bensalem incident, Mathis allegedly entered a Metro by T-Mobile store in Philadelphia, displayed a black semi-automatic handgun, and stole cash before fleeing northbound into Bucks County. Those charges remain pending in Philadelphia.
Following the outcome of the trial, District Attorney Joe Khan praised the seasoned trial team prosecutors – who were hired back to the office earlier this year – and the bravery of the officers involved.
“Bringing back seasoned, battle-tested prosecutors like Megan and Cate has bolstered our ability to hold violent repeat offenders accountable,” Khan said. “This verdict is a testament to their courtroom expertise and the bravery of the Bensalem police officer who stepped directly into harm’s way to stop an armed suspect. My office will always stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the dedicated men and women in uniform who keep Bucks County safe.”
Bucks County Detectives William Mooney and Kelcy Pitts investigated the case, along with Deputy District Attorney Megan Hunsicker. Deputy District Attorneys Megan Stricker and Catherine Pirolli successfully handled this prosecution.



Recent Comments