A King of Prussia man will spend up to 23 months in Bucks County Prison for his obsessive stalking campaign of a Bensalem woman which forced her to move.
Common Pleas Judge Wallace H. Bateman Jr. sentenced Matthew John Bustin, 34, of King of Prussia, to nine to 23 months in county jail and seven years of probation. During the sentencing hearing on Thursday, Deputy District Attorney Brittney Kern presented a detailed timeline of Bustin’s actions, which included online searches of the victim before he contacted her on a dating site.
The timeline shows that in the weeks after the victim began communicating with Bustin, he was charged in a similar stalking case in Lehigh County. The victim only talked to Bustin for six weeks before his disturbing behavior led to her filing a police report.
In the Lehigh County case, Bustin was sentenced up to 24 months in prison following a stalking spree that included placing a GPS tracker on his victim’s car and sending eerie gifts in Bethlehem, the Lehigh County District Attorney’s Office announced earlier this year.
According to court records, when the Bensalem victim arrived back home from vacation she discovered the power to her apartment was cut, her internet connection was “manually” shut off and a security camera were disabled. She called Bensalem Police to report the suspicious incident, court records show with the investigation moving from unusual to downright terrifying.
“I truly believed there was someone in my apartment with me,” she stated. She said she waited in her kitchen with a knife and called a friend for help. She described the “scariest part” as “knowing someone had been in my apartment… yet still not knowing who would do this.”
She filed a police report the next day. Within two days of filing the police report, she was in so much fear that she moved out. The victim continued to sleep with a knife next to her bed. In what she described as “a heart-stopping moment,” she found a note tucked among the pillows. The discovery, which she described as a “sick psychological game,” confirmed her fears that Bustin was her stalker.
Bensalem Detectives examined her vehicle and located a GPS tracker on the underside of the vehicle. Investigators filed a search warrant to recover data from the tracking device. Tracker data showed that it began transmitting the location of the victim’s car on April 5, 2024, at the victim’s workplace in Montgomery County. The detective then obtained surveillance video from the business and observed a male get out of a black Honda Civic. He walks towards the victim’s car, lies on the ground, reaches underneath the vehicle, and then returns to his car. The male and the Honda Civic match the description of Matthew Bustin and the vehicle he drives, police said in the criminal complaint.
A second search warrant was obtained by police for Bustin’s cellular data which showed the suspect was in the area of the victims home and workplace at least nine times, the criminal complaint says, without her knowledge after she ended the relationship.
In her statement, the victim reflected on Bustin’s history, noting that he was charged in the Lehigh County stalking case around the time he called her for the first time. “The immediacy of recurrence is scary,” she said. “This is not the behavior of someone who has learned from past repercussions, and it isn’t the behavior of someone who feels remorseful,” according to a release from the DA’s office.
As a condition of his sentence, Bustin will not be eligible for parole until he completes the H.O.P.E. substance abuse recovery program. He has also been ordered to have no contact with the victim or on any social media sites. He must pay $1,334.60 in restitution, and comply with all mental health and drug and alcohol requirements, Bucks County authorities said.
As part of his supervision the Bucks County Department of Probation will get to legally stalk Bustin for seven years in a flip the script situation for the felon.