Voice of the People: Repeal Act 38 of 2020: Modified Stop-Arm Camera Law Is Unjust
The following submission was submitted to the Lower Bucks Source “Voice of the People” Op-Ed section. The views and opinions expressed in the submission are those of the writer.
The submission is in direct response to a story published on September 24, 2022, titled ” Bensalem Police Report 25 Red Light Violations Per School Day in Spite of Bus Cameras”
In the state legislature, Act 38 of 2020 sadly became law, and should be repealed.
This measure modified the stop-arm camera law for illegally passing school buses. It assumes a vehicle’s owner was driving, and takes away motorists rights. Will also allow multiple entities to reap profits, based upon the number of tickets, which will act as an incentive to make sure the tickets keep flowing.The goal should be to prevent illegal school bus passing, not try to rake in revenue without trying to correct a potential problem.
The law will do nothing to solve anything, as that is not the point.
Where is the requirement for a minimum flashing yellow duration? How about mandating stop-arm extenders to block the next lane? Making bus stops only on the right side of the bus to prevent crossing the roads? Adults to cross the kids, as some areas do? Moving bus stops to smaller roads and away from intersections?
If a flashing yellow is too short, what is the incentive to fix it? Same for moving bus stops to more suitable locations. In some places you may not see a bus, may not be able to safely stop, or not know if you must stop.
Pennsylvania law differs from those of most states, as there is no nationwide standard. You will not see a bus on intersecting roads.
What happens if you are already near the bus when the lights change to flashing reds? Are split-second violations issued? Also, people may end up slamming the brakes or flooring it, if they think they could get tickets. This would actually create an unsafe situation, perhaps?
James Sikorski Jr. PA Advocate National Motorists Association.
The above was edited according to Associated Press standards and guideline for news organizations only.
For information on how to submit your op-ed to the VOP section, please click here
I agree with this. Fixing a problem is the thing to do, not simply try to generate revenue. I also pulled up the NMA site, which has a lot of good info, including a variety of independent studies people can read.